Assignment or Test |
Contribution to Final Grade |
Lecture Presentation
|
20%
|
Preliminary outline for lecture presentation
|
5%
|
Student-led scientific paper discussion
|
20%
|
Designing and marking a question directed to the student-led scientific paper discussion
|
5%
|
Answers to questions on scientific papers (6 in total x 5% answer)
|
30%
|
Participation
|
20%
|
Additional Notes:
Lecture Presentation on a Topic in Plant Metabolism (25% of final grade)
This assignment will provide students with an opportunity to deliver an advanced 50-min participatory/active learning lecture on a topic in plant metabolism. It is worth 30% of the final grade in the course (20% for the presentation and 5% for a lecture outline). Questions can be asked by the audience anytime during the lecture, and student presenters should anticipate 10 min for questions when designing the lecture. Your lecture presentation should provide an accurate representation of our present state of knowledge for the topic. In terms of the ‘big picture’, also attempt to address the relevance of the topic to plant physiology, and the practical relevance of the topic. The complete list of references used in preparing the PowerPoint presentation should be listed at the end of your PowerPoint presentation, and these references should be cited within the lecture presentation where appropriate. Detailed guidelines for the lecture presentation including the marking scheme are provided on CourseLink.
Student-led Discussion of a Scientific Paper (25% of final grade)
This assignment will consist of two parts: (i) a 50-min lecture presentation (40-min lecture & ~10 min for questions) (20% of final grade); and (ii) a detailed outline of the lecture presentation provided no less than 2 weeks before the actual lecture presentation (5% of final grade). This assignment will provide students with an opportunity to deliver an advanced 50-min participatory/active learning lecture on a topic in plant metabolism. Questions can be asked by the audience anytime during the lecture, and student presenters should anticipate ~10 min for questions and discussion when designing the lecture. Topics must be chosen in consultation with the instructor by Sept 30 to provide a complementary selection of topics. A detailed outline of the lecture presentation must be handed into the instructor for marking no less than 2 weeks before the actual lecture presentation. The following must be provided to the instructor 4 days prior to the scheduled presentation for posting on CourseLink: (1) a final version of the PowerPoint presentation in .ppt format; and (2) pdf copies of 3 relevant review papers from the scientific literature for posting on CourseLink.
Your lecture presentation should provide an accurate representation of our present state of knowledge for that topic. In terms of the ‘big picture’, also attempt to address the relevance of the topic to plant function, and the practical relevance of the topic. The complete list of references used in preparing the PowerPoint presentation should be listed at the end of your PowerPoint presentation, and these references should be cited within the lecture presentation where appropriate.
Detailed guidelines for the lecture presentation, including the lecture outline, are provided in a separate document on CourseLink.
Student-led Presentation and Discussion of a Scientific Paper-Weeks 10-12 (25% of final grade)
This assignment will consist of two parts: (i) a 50-min student-led presentation and discussion of an original scientific paper (20% of final grade); and (ii) the development and marking of a question directed to the scientific paper (5% of final grade). IMPORTANT: the scientific paper chosen by each student should be directly relevant to the topic discussed by them in the previous lecture presentation. This will allow the class to have some background relevant to the scientific paper. Compared to the lecture presentation, the student-led paper discussion will require a greater emphasis on methodology, experimental design, and data analysis and interpretation, and it will be more focused overall. Detailed guidelines for the student-led scientific paper presentation including the marking scheme are provided in a separate document on CourseLink. See Section 5(a) above for the policy regarding a missed presentation.
Initially, students should provide the instructor with 2-3 original scientific papers they would like to discuss, and then in consultation with the instructor one of these papers will be selected for the student-led presentation and discussion. Scientific papers must be chosen in consultation with the course instructor by Oct 14 to provide a complementary selection of topics. A pdf of the scientific paper will be posted on CourseLink by the instructor once finalized. The selected scientific paper will provide the basis for the discussion. The discussion will consist of two parts: (1) an uninterrupted PowerPoint presentation of the scientific paper that is no more than 20-min & 15 slides in length, not including the title slide and literature cited slide(s); and (2) a ~30 min informal student-led discussion of the scientific paper. The 20-min PowerPoint presentation is to consist of the following items: (1) up to 4 introductory slides (not including the title slide) that provide the objective(s) of the paper, rationale for the experimental design, and any necessary background information; (2) a discussion of up to 5 key figures and/or tables from the scientific paper using up to 2 slides per figure or table (i.e. up to 10 slides total), such that relevant methods, and the results and conclusions are provided; (3) no more than one slide providing the main conclusion(s) from the paper and future directions; and (4) additional slide(s) providing the Literature Cited. Thus, the 20-min presentation should consist of no more than 15 well-designed slides + a title slide and slide(s) for the Literature Cited. A copy of your PowerPoint presentation in ppt format must be provided to the instructor during the class it is presented for posting on CourseLink after the presentation is complete. This PowerPoint presentation is not provided to the class beforehand, since that would defeat the purpose of the exercise.
The 30-min student-led discussion can include any aspects of the scientific paper, including data not discussed during the 20-min presentation, and potential applications to the improvement of agriculture, forestry, etc. To encourage discussion, it is recommended that each class member prepares two questions or comments directed to the scientific paper prior to class.
A question directed to the scientific paper that is being presented in the student-led paper presentation will be developed by the presenter and answered by the class for marking. The question must be provided to the instructor for posting on CourseLink no later than two weeks prior to the student-led presentation. The goal of this assignment is to encourage a detailed reading of the paper to be presented in the student-led discussion. Questions should foster an in-depth analysis of the paper and can include:
- Queries as to the hypothesis being tested, and how the experiment(s) allowed the hypothesis to be tested including the quality of the experiment(s);
- Explanation of a methodology and how it was critical in addressing a scientific question;
- Design of the next critical experiments to further the research area;
- Analysis of data and methodology to assess limitations in the study;
- Anything you think is appropriate.
Questions will be marked by the presenting student. A scanned pdf of the marked copies of the student answers is due to the instructor by Sunday of the next week by 4 pm for final approval of the grade. The quality of both the question and the marking of the question will be assessed by the instructor for 5% of your final grade. When developing a marking scheme for marking the question, the total score should add up to at least 20 points to prevent too large a deduction per point. Detailed guidelines for developing and marking the questions, including the marking scheme, are provided in a separate document on Courselink.
Answering Questions Directed to Scientific-Paper Discussions (30% of final grade)
During Weeks 1-5 the course instructor will provide four questions directed to a scientific paper. Three of the four questions must be answered and handed in for marking. Each answer is worth 5% of the final grade for a total of 15% of the final grade. If all four questions are answered, the best 3 out of 4 marks will be used to calculate the final grade.
In addition, during Weeks 10-12 each student presenter will provide the class with one question directed to their student-led scientific paper presentation (see 5(c)), and answers will be marked by the student presenter. The best 4 marks will be used to calculate the final grade (5% each) for a total of 20% of the final grade. Thus, there is the option to answer only 2 questions or to answer more if you believe this will improve your overall grade. Each answer will have a word limit of 1 double-spaced page per question (12-font, New Times Roman, 2.5 cm margins all).
Answers to the questions provided both by the course instructor and student presenters are due to the course instructor (not the student presenter) as a hard copy in class just before the scientific paper presentation begins; they cannot be handed in at a later time. Detailed guidelines for answering the questions, including the marking scheme, are provided in a separate document on CourseLink.
Detailed guidelines for developing and marking the questions including the marking scheme are provided on CourseLink. The quality of both the question and the marking of the question will be assessed by the course instructor for a total of 5% of the final grade.
Regarding the questions marked by student presenters, a scanned version of the marked hard copies of the answers are due to the instructor by Sunday of the next week by 4 pm for final approval of the grade. The quality of both the question and the marking of the question will be assessed by the instructor for 5% of the final grade.
Class Participation (20% of final grade)
Level of class participation will be determined by the instructor through: (i) participation in class discussions; (ii) the quality of evaluation of student presentations (see Sections 5(a) and 5(b) above); (iii) conforming to instructions, including due dates; and (iv) class attendance. Each of these 4 components will constitute 5% of your final grade for a total of 20%, and participation components can overlap (e.g. if you miss a class, it will affect (i) and (vi) and it could affect (ii)). For (iv), class attendance, one % point of the final grade will be deducted for each missed class regardless of the reason.